Demanding an End to Constant Workplace Connection Around the Clock

Demanding an End to Constant Workplace Connection Around the Clock

European Workers Face Growing Pressure Due to Unrelenting Connectivity

In an era of rapid technological advancement, workers across Europe are grappling with mounting pressure, unlimited working hours, and escalating stress levels. As the day concludes, or employees log off their computers, many find themselves reconnecting, whether at home or on their smartphones, engrossed in extra hours or anxiously awaiting work-related messages.

This unsettling trend can be partly attributed to the proliferation of new technologies that foster round-the-clock connectivity, intensifying work pressures and promoting an unhealthy work-life balance. Consequently, the implementation of a comprehensive EU-wide legislation guaranteeing the "right to disconnect" has become a pressing necessity.

In June 2022, the European Trade Union Confederation (ETUC) and employers signed a joint Work Programme that included a commitment to reach a legally binding agreement to regulate telework and foster the right to disconnect, intended to be manifested in a directive. Following 15 months of negotiations, the social partners were on the brink of agreement, but employers ultimately blocked the deal owing to a lack of unanimity within their ranks.

Now, the responsibility lies with the European Commission to propose a directive. Prior to the European elections in 2024, the old Commission initiated the first phase of a social partner consultation, subsequently presenting its proposals in April of that year. The ETUC responded promptly to the questions posed in the consultation, and the new Commission, led by Executive Vice-President for Social Rights, Quality Jobs and Preparedness, Roxana Minzatu, had pledged to make this a priority. However, the expected new proposal has yet to materialize, leaving trade unions waiting in limbo.

An ambitious directive on telework and the right to disconnect could significantly improve the working conditions in an increasingly digitalized environment. The Commission's apparent reluctance to push forward with this initiative is perplexing, given the immediate implications of over-connectivity on workers' lives.

Long working hours, stress, anxiety, and depression have become increasingly prevalent work-related health issues in Europe, with these problems reaching epidemic proportions even prior to the COVID-19 pandemic. Following the crisis, a 2022 Flash Eurobarometer survey by the European Agency for Health and Safety at Work (EU-OSHA) found that 46% of respondents complained of severe time pressure or overload of work. Chronic stress can lead to depression, family breakdowns, and even suicide.

The surge in teleworking brought about by the pandemic has further compounded the problem. While recognizing the potential benefits of working from home, trade unions insist that rules and regulations are essential to address this exponential growth in the digital economy, which has led to new work patterns, insecure contracts, platform work, AI digitalization, and increased availability for employers, ultimately placing pressure on workers. In 2023, EU-OSHA highlighted "permanent availability" as a grave danger to workers' safety and health.

A legally binding right to disconnect is crucial to stemming this tide and fostering a healthy work-life balance. Eurofound research from November 2023 found that health problems were more common among employees who worked unsocial hours, indicating higher levels of anxiety and exhaustion and a greater risk to their health due to their work. Employees regularly working from home were six times more likely to work in their free time and twice as likely to work 48 hours.

Given the serious implications of this matter, particularly for women who bear the bulk of family responsibilities, the lack of progress towards an EU-wide, enforceable right to disconnect is alarming. The demand for such legislation is not new; a European Parliament resolution in January 2021 recognized it as a fundamental employee right and called for a directive to ensure employees "can disconnect outside their working hours" and to "establish minimum requirements for remote working and clarify working conditions, hours, and rest periods."

At the national level, some progress has been made. France was the first country to pass a right-to-disconnect law in 2016, while Belgium, Italy, Portugal, and several other countries have introduced or proposed legislation in this area. However, the absence of a unified EU-wide approach persists, leaving workers in various member states with varying degrees of protection.

The need for decisive action from the European Commission cannot be overstated. In the quest for a healthier, more balanced workforce, the right to disconnect stands as a pivotal issue that requires immediate attention.

1. The European Trade Union Confederation (ETUC) and employers have agreed to work together on a Work Programme, aiming to regulate telework and establish the right to disconnect.
2. Health and safety concerns, particularly mental health, are escalating due to the over-connectivity and long working hours in Europe's digitalized work environment.
3. Trade unions advocate for a comprehensive EU-wide legislation that guarantees the right to disconnect, as they believe it could improve working conditions and promote a healthy work-life balance.
4. The lack of progress towards a legally binding EU-wide right to disconnect, deemed a fundamental employee right by the European Parliament, is a matter of grave concern, particularly for women who bear the brunt of family responsibilities.

Read also: